Perodua’s first EV – and its first totally homegrown product – hasn’t had the beginning that the corporate would’ve hoped. Launched late final yr, the QV-E was saddled with not only a RM80,000 price ticket but additionally a obligatory battery leasing plan with a nine-year contract that consumers balked at, with gross sales solely reaching 182 items in its first six months in the marketplace.
That’s not a superb look for an organization that offered 24,480 automobiles final month alone. And it doesn’t assist that the QV-E has been haemorrhaging gross sales to the Proton eMas 5, which offered greater than 52 occasions that quantity with 9,569 items reaching prospects’ arms over precisely the identical interval.
However Perodua is now staging a comeback with a large worth drop for the QV-E. With a RM6,500 rebate operating till September 30, the automobile now retails at RM63,499 with battery leasing – a greater than RM16,500 discount. The leasing price has now been lowered from RM275 per thirty days to RM215. For the primary time, the corporate can also be providing all-in pricing with the battery included, which can set you again RM87,499 – simply RM7,499 greater than the launch worth that excluded the battery within the first place.
With that, it’s time to take a look at the QV-E versus Proton’s large vendor as soon as once more. How do the unchanged specs examine, particularly when reframed with the brand new pricing in thoughts? We’ll reply all these and extra on this head-to-head comparability.
Pricing now far more aggressive
There’s little question that the QV-E has simply turn into a way more enticing proposition. Whereas beforehand, the QV-E would’ve run you as much as almost RM110,000 with 9 years of battery leasing included (excluding rent buy rates of interest, after all), this determine is now slightly below RM87,000. With outright pricing being solely barely greater than that, prospects have the luxurious of alternative.
Granted, this nonetheless makes the QV-E a step costlier than the eMas 5, which even in its priciest Premium trim prices simply RM69,800 (RM56,800 for the Prime). But it surely’s a lot nearer now, and this repositioning additionally strikes the automobile away from the highly-competitive C-segment SUV market occupied by the likes of the eMas 7 and the BYD Atto 3. These are achieved machines that the Perodua can’t hope to compete, for causes that may turn into obvious afterward.
In a giant boon for present homeowners, their battery subscription worth additionally drops to RM215 per thirty days, and they’re additionally entitled to a “particular refund” on their buy worth of RM80,000. Whether or not the total quantity can be returned stays to be seen, however this can be a uncommon concession for many who already personal the automobile.
The worth minimize exhibits the disparity in present fortunes between Perodua and Proton. The previous claims that the discount comes as a part of elevated localisation, with the financial savings being handed on to the buyer. That could be true, however we suspect the corporate wouldn’t have made the QV-E a lot cheaper so quickly had its market efficiency been extra encouraging – this isn’t a agency that tends to offer large reductions when gross sales are good, in any case.
By comparability, the robust gross sales of the eMas 5 – and lack of any actual competitors – imply that Proton has not been pressured to scale back the automobile’s costs, even after shifting to native meeting beginning this month. That stands in stark distinction to the eMas 7, which fell by as much as RM6,000 beginning early this yr because it continued to battle with the Atto 3 for sophistication supremacy.
This does sting considerably, however you need to keep in mind that the eMas 5 (by that we imply its twin, the Geely Xingyuan) is in-built enormous numbers in China, the place the Xingyuan is the best-selling automobile for the previous two years. In the meantime, the QV-E is at present made in such small numbers – Perodua is nearly a boutique carmaker at this level – that any financial savings from localisation will make a big distinction to the ultimate worth.
With the eMas 5, it’s the alternative – Geely having to construct 1000’s of specialized knocked-down (KD) kits for Malaysia could have seemingly resulted in price will increase, so it’s no large shock that Proton hasn’t lowered the value. Even with all that taken under consideration, nonetheless, the eMas 5 stays the undisputed worth champion. However will this stay the case as soon as we dig into the remainder of what the 2 automobiles have to supply?
QV-E the efficiency, vary benchmark; eMas 5 prices sooner
Early on, the QV-E notches a vital victory. So far as efficiency goes, it wipes the ground with the eMas 5, providing almost double the ability of even essentially the most highly effective model of the Proton. Its entrance motor makes 204 PS (150 kW) and 285 Nm of torque, versus the rear-drive eMas 5 Premium’s 116 PS (85 kW) and 150 Nm.
It’s no shock, then, that the Perodua is pretty brisk, getting from zero to 100 km/h in 7.5 seconds on its approach to a high velocity of 165 km/h. Proton – or relatively, Geely – has spare the eMas 5 its blushes by not quoting a zero-to-100 km/h time, solely an irrelevant zero-to-50 km/h determine of three.9 seconds.
The QV-E’s benefit extends to its vary. Each automobiles supply their LFP batteries from CATL, however the Perodua’s 52.5 kWh pack dwarfs the eMas 5 Premium’s 40.16 kWh unit, which is why it is ready to journey a lot additional on the WLTP cycle – 370 km versus the Proton’s 325 km. A distinction of 45 km could not seem to be a lot on paper, however it might imply one or two further days of driving earlier than needing a cost. And on automobiles which are as range-starved as these, each little counts.
We must always level out that in China, the Xingyuan has simply been upgraded with a bigger 47.14 kWh battery, delivering a spread of 480 km on the Center Kingdom’s ridiculously lenient CLTC cycle. This could equate to a WLTP determine of round 390 km, which is just a bit additional than the QV-E (and demonstrates simply how far more environment friendly this automobile is). Will we get this larger pack afterward? We’ll simply have to attend and see.
The place Perodua has dropped the ball is in charging. The QV-E solely helps as much as a measly 60 kW of DC quick charging, which is identical as what the eMas 7 PHEV is able to. As such, it takes a yawning half-hour for the battery to be topped up from 30 to 80%.
The mixture of a smaller battery and the next DC charging capability of 71 kW means the eMas 5 Premium is ready to be out and in of the charger 9 minutes faster, taking simply 21 minutes to achieve the identical benchmark. And whereas each will settle for 6.6 kW from an AC wallbox charger, the QV-E takes eight hours for a full cost, whereas the Proton will want 5.9 hours of your time to be juiced from 10 to 100%.
QV-E provides extra equipment; eMas 5 extra sensible and higher high quality
There’s no denying that by way of showroom enchantment, the QV-E has the measure of the eMas 5, not less than the place the outside is worried. Whereas the Proton’s jellybean form is a typical sight lately, the Perodua cuts a high-quality determine with its sharp styling, coupé-like roofline and hidden rear door handles. If sportiness is what you’re on the lookout for, it’s not even a contest.
We are able to’t say which design strategy works finest for you – cutesy with vivid colors, or jutting and aggressive – however to us the QV-E is definitely the looker of the 2. Its kerb enchantment is bolstered by the truth that it rolls on fashionable 18-inch alloy wheels which are two inches larger than the castors on the eMas 5.
Each automobiles are shod with sub-par Chinese language price range tyres – Atlas A3 on the QV-E, Linglong Consolation Grasp on the eMas 5. And in the event you’re seeking to change them with premium rubber from the get-go, as we might advocate, the Proton’s smaller tyre dimension means it’ll be less expensive to switch all 4. Each automobiles function disc brakes throughout and journey on MacPherson strut suspension on the entrance; the QV-E will get a easy torsion beam on the rear, whereas the eMas 5 receives a extra subtle impartial multilink setup on the rear.
One limitation that hurts the QV-E is the variety of colors on supply. There are simply two, and each are pretty comparable pale-bluish metallic shades – Ice Blue and Caviar Gray. Then again, the eMas 5 could be had in quite a lot of enjoyable hues, together with Marble Cream, Quartz Rose and my private favorite, the recently-introduced Jade Inexperienced.
Step inside and at first look, the QV-E seems to take care of its lead. Its inside options soft-touch supplies as a substitute of the exhausting plastics prevalent within the eMas 5, and it comes with such niceties as a powered driver’s seat and even a digital rear-view mirror.
Its 10.25-inch instrument show can also be bigger than the eMas 5’s slimline 8.8-inch unit, and whereas its touchscreen (additionally 10.25 inches throughout) is eclipsed by the Proton’s huge 14.6-inch panel, you do profit from bodily air-con controls (with an auto operate besides). Each automobiles include wi-fi Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, though the Proton does get built-in navigation with a neat built-in charging map.
Dig deeper and the QV-E begins to lose its lustre. To start with, the eMas 5 is far more sensible – regardless of being barely shorter in size (4,135 mm vs 4,170 mm) and wheelbase (2,650 mm vs 2,680 mm), it provides extra legroom for passengers behind, whereas the Perodua’s sloping roof robs rear headroom. The Proton’s further peak (1,580 mm vs 1,502 mm) additionally permits the rear seats to be mounted increased, permitting for extra pure seating in comparison with the QV-E’s knees-up positioning.
The QV-E isn’t simply extra cramped for rear-seat occupants, it feels it too, with black headlining and tiny rear home windows proscribing outward visibility. Entry and egress can also be restricted by the small rear door aperture, which isn’t excellent news for these wanting to suit little one seats. Additional factors within the eMas 5’s favour are its pair of rear air vents (none within the Perodua) and the helpful 28 litres of under-seat storage.
On the again, the eMas 5 trumps the QV-E with a powered tailgate, and as soon as open, you’ll discover a bigger 375 litre boot, versus 320 litres for the Perodua. The rear-mounted motor additionally frees up area within the entrance for a beneficiant 70-litre boot, so in the event you’re hauling durians on the common, the eMas 5 is the clear winner.
After which we come to the a part of the comparability that the specs don’t inform you, and it’s how the automobiles really feel inside. That is the place the QV-E actually begins to battle – sure, you’ll discover higher supplies, however the automobile squanders this benefit each by its design (flat dashboard, too-thick steering wheel spokes, too-small headrests) and the standard (tough part-fabric upholstery, swaths of low cost silver plastic, underdamped door handles).
Don’t get me flawed, the eMas 5 is not any Rolls-Royce by comparability, however it nails the fundamentals and has nicer fake leather-based upholstery. You too can go for an Alabaster White inside which, whereas straightforward to stain, lifts the atmosphere past the dour Flint Gray. The Proton could really feel prefer it’s constructed to a worth, however it additionally feels (and appears) prefer it’s constructed to the next customary.
It’s clear that Perodua is a era or two behind Proton (once more, Geely on this case) in these areas. Some could also be extra forgiving of those foibles, however to us, these little issues mix to make the QV-E much less of a “correct” automobile, which makes the steeper worth even more durable to swallow.
Security-wise, each the QV-E and eMas 5 are a lot of a muchness with six airbags and Degree 2 semi-autonomous driving features corresponding to adaptive cruise management and lane centring help. The Perodua provides a rear-seat reminder that the Proton lacks, with a novel ultrasonic sensor for detecting rear occupants, relatively than merely utilizing door opening and shutting logic.
Package rely is just a part of the story – of better significance is the precise security efficiency, and the QV-E is the one one to have scored a five-star ASEAN NCAP ranking. The eMas 5 has but to be crash examined by any international security company, however on condition that it is going to be offered in Europe and Australia because the Geely EX2, count on the standard Euro NCAP and ANCAP rankings quickly.
Effectivity and operating prices
Whereas the QV-E provides extra vary, the figures counsel that the eMas 5 is extra environment friendly, reaching 12.4 kWh per 100 km versus 14.2 kWh per 100 km for the Perodua (you possibly can blame the additional 300 kg for this). The caveat, after all, is that these numbers have been calculated utilizing the automobiles’ WLTP ranges, and you’ll invariably devour extra vitality in the true world.
All issues being equal, nonetheless, the QV-E will seemingly price extra to cost in the long term, though its longer vary could give drivers extra leeway to seek for cheaper charging choices to scale back operating prices. So it’s swings and roundabouts, actually.
When it comes to guarantee protection, the QV-E comes with a six-year/150,000 km guarantee, which the eMas 5 beats by having no mileage cap. Perodua touts a complete service price of RM2,520.50 over 9 years or 180,000 km, and whereas Proton’s service schedule is barely completely different (there’s an preliminary service at 5,000 km, which P2 skips in favour of a complimentary inspection at 1,000 km), even at 9 years and three months or 185,000 km, the eMas 5 is predicted to price simply RM2,275.15 in upkeep, which is a good saving.
Moreover, each automobiles (in the event you go for outright pricing for the QV-E) include an eight-year/160,000 km battery guarantee, with Perodua guaranteeing a substitute if the state of well being falls under 70% earlier than the guarantee is out. Proton hasn’t outright said if it provides the identical assure for the eMas 5, however it seemingly does so, in keeping with the bigger eMas 7.
After all, with the QV-E, you do get the choice of battery leasing, which Perodua claims guards consumers in opposition to battery degradation and extreme EV depreciation. The RM215 month-to-month charge covers any upkeep on the battery (not lined underneath the common service schedule, so no financial savings there), and similar to with the battery guarantee, the corporate will change the battery if its well being drops under 70% in the course of the lease interval.
Nonetheless, any battery substitute after the lease requires consumers to signal a brand new nine-year leasing contract, trapping you into one other lengthy cost cycle. You additionally need to pay a steep three-month upfront advance cost of RM645 earlier than you get your automobile, though this does cowl the ultimate three months of your lease.
Plus, each used car sale must be both carried out by or facilitated by Perodua’s Pre-Owned Automobile (POV) service, and the brand new purchaser has to signal a brand new nine-year lease contract. And on condition that the corporate doesn’t present a assured future worth for the QV-E, you possibly can’t make certain if its resale worth claims maintain any water, both.
Additionally, you will by no means personal the battery outright – even as soon as the lease funds finish after these 9 years, the pack will nonetheless belong to Perodua, for higher or worse. You might be additionally locked into your determination to lease the battery the second you place cash down; you possibly can’t purchase it after the actual fact, and in the event you’re an present proprietor and wish to change, your solely recourse is to promote your automobile and purchase one other one. All in all, the scheme simply doesn’t appear well worth the bother.
All this goes on high of the truth that the eMas 5 Premium is usefully cheaper to purchase outright than the QV-E within the first place, to the tune of RM17,699. This covers a superb chunk (if not all) of the price of a battery substitute, so you possibly can successfully purchase three batteries for the value of a QV-E – the one which comes with the automobile, a free substitute underneath guarantee if the primary one dips under 70% SoH, and one other substitute after that. If that’s not sufficient of a safeguard in opposition to battery degradation, I don’t know what’s.
Closing verdict
On the finish of the day, which among the many Perodua QV-E and Proton eMas 5 is finest for you is dependent upon what you’re on the lookout for. If it’s all-out efficiency and vary you’re after, then the QV-E wins, arms down. For the cash, it will get nearer to the category above (eMas 7, Atto 3) in these areas, though it stumbles on the subject of charging speeds.
However in a reversal of roles, it’s the Proton that’s the extra sensible alternative. Fairly aside from the truth that it’s less expensive to purchase, the eMas 5 Premium ought to price much less to run and provides extra space for passengers and baggage, plus it’s sooner to cost.
It’s additionally exhausting to overstate the gulf in high quality between the 2 automobiles, which is much less of a praise to the eMas 5 and extra of a criticism of simply how poor the QV-E is inside. Final however not least, there’s the choice of a fair cheaper Prime to avoid wasting much more cash, albeit on the expense of vary (simply 225 km WLTP) and lively security options.
There are different choices too, together with the eMas 7 Prime and the BYD Atto 2. Extremely, there are nonetheless tax-free 2025 items of the latter accessible, and with numerous rebates and offers round, each could be had for not far more further outlay. They could ship a shorter vary at 345 km on the WLTP cycle, however they’re bigger and supply a lot nicer cabins than the QV-E.
Nonetheless, the QV-E does stand alone as Malaysia’s solely homegrown EV, which does rely for one thing. For those who can look previous its numerous faults, the newest worth minimize – and the flexibility to buy the battery outright – signifies that shopping for one is now a way more rational determination.
GALLERY: Perodua QV-E
GALLERY: Proton eMas 5 Premium
Seeking to promote your automobile? Promote it with Carro.